Support the Café

Search our Site

What do you do with Alcohol? Welcome it, but welcome all of it: the good, the bad, and the transformational.

What do you do with Alcohol? Welcome it, but welcome all of it: the good, the bad, and the transformational.

On occassion, we will publish letters to the Editor addressing recent stories or events.  These letters do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Episcopal Cafẻ.


by Scott Petersen

As Episcopalians, I believe we need to own that we are a church that welcomes alcohol. To deny that reality is to deny a part of our ethos. Alcohol, and its use, points to part of the fabric of our common life. I say welcome alcohol, but welcome all of it: the good, the bad, and the transformational.


Alcoholics Anonymous is hosting their International Convention this summer July 2nd-July 5th. To welcome people in recovery from around the country, All Saint’s Episcopal Church in Atlanta, in nearby proximity to the GA Dome, will be hosting a special Eucharist and meal ahead of the “Big Meeting” on Saturday night. At 5PM on Saturday July 4th, we’ll have a 12 Step Eucharist for all who find themselves on the road for AA’s International Convention. All who come will find a faith-community open to recovery just as much as it is to alcohol.


AA turns 80 this year. Atlanta is expecting 50K to 70K alcoholics in recovery. This year, the GA Dome in Atlanta will be the site for the “Big Meeting” both Friday night and Saturday night at 8pm. To welcome all who come, the Episcopal Diocese of Atlanta is trying to get the word out about this special worship and welcome. (Please share this article and links both within the church and to all you might know in recovery.)


I chuckle some that I’m sharing that as a church we need to own our particular identity around alcohol. This is amazing to me personally because, while I am a clergyperson and a member of our church, I have been sober in AA for 19 years. You might think I’d be against alcohol. I’m not. AA has been instrumental in my formation as a person of faith and as a priest. Of all the churches that God could have led me to, I found home in, was received by, and ordained a priest in the one known for “whiskeypalians” and where I have often heard “wherever there are 4 Episcopalians there is a Fifth.” Trust me, I am and have always been amazed and humored by the irony of living one day at a time as priest in the Episcopal Church.


Such contrast often makes for good comedy… except, when it doesn’t.


On the flipside, as both a priest of the Episcopal Church and person in recovery it has been painful to watch some of the news as it rolled by this past year. Like watching a slow train wreck we witnessed a Diocese embroiled by the turmoil a single alcoholic can bring about. There has been hand wringing and reactivity. In reaction to all the negative press which followed it has also been interesting to read the second guessing about proposed cocktail parties and events with alcohol planned for General Convention in Salt Lake City.


I don’t believe reactivity, hand wringing or second guessing is the way to go forward. Blame will hardly do the trick either. The correct path our church should follow when it comes to alcohol is a both/and rather than a neither/nor. As church we need to own that alcohol is “ok” in our church. As church, we need to recognize, support, and be clear that for those struggling with it, that its “no” at times, is a loving response. As church we need not lose sight of the tremendous gifts shared to the church by those in recovery. We are strengthened by those who have found alcohol a problem and are now living into recovery one day at a time.


In Atlanta on the 4th, we are not going to change our stripes. We are not going to deny that there are Episcopalians who like Sherry or Scotch. Our approach this summer is simply to welcome. We hope to welcome Episcopalians and all others from many places who have come to Atlanta to be a part of AA’s 80th year. We’re glad they’re coming. We look forward to meeting you.


AA recognized early the folly of being or even trying to be a temperance movement. It has always been about helping the next alcoholic down the road and helping that one live in a world where alcohol is readily available. This approach to alcohol and its impact is key and should remain our model. It is both/and. As church we need to welcome the fact that for those of legal age, drinking alcohol is not a hindrance to a mature, robust faith. As church, we need to not shy away from but embrace that there are those for whom the successful consumption of alcohol is a problem. Borrowing from AA’s big book, “For them, to drink is to die.”


Welcome alcohol but welcome all of it: the good, the bad, and the transformational. Our faith, after all, is about transformation. Let the reactivity, hand wringing and second guessing go. As church we can learn from AA in this moment. “Let go and let God.” Welcome alcohol as a part of who we are. At the same time recognize and provide means to help our fellows who might suffer from it. Recognize, more importantly, that maybe, the fellow Episcopalian whom you admire for their Christian walk, may have learned at least a part of their walk in other “anonymous” places.


If that is you and you are coming to Atlanta this summer for the AA Convention, be it with one day of sobriety or 40+ years, we hope we see you Saturday night at All Saints Episcopal Church. Join us for worship and a meal. Join us and as the Big Book points out,, We shall be with you in the Fellowship of the Spirit, and you will surely meet some of us as you trudge the Road of Happy Destiny.” See you in Atlanta for AA’s Convention and at All Saints July 4th!


For more information, directions, and contact info about the worship and dinner please see:


To learn more or to consider coming to Atlanta for AA’s International Convention please see:


The Rev. Scott Petersen is a “friend of Bill” and priest at All Saints Warner Robins in the Episcopal Diocese of Atlanta. This article supports both persons in recovery and the ministry of All Saints’ Atlanta in partnership with All Saints Warner Robins and The Episcopal Diocese of Atlanta. He is glad to be living further into this special ministry partnership. It should be known that while he greatly appreciates the partnership and its development, the views expressed here are solely his own.


Café Comments?

Our comment policy requires that you use your real first and last names and provide an email address (your email will not be published). Comments that use non-PG rated language, include personal attacks, that are not provable as fact or that we deem in any way to be counter to our mission of fostering respectful dialogue will not be posted.

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Margaret Dunsta

While the Episcopal Church has guidelines for alcohol, I have found that sometimes our congregations need to know more about alcoholism. Many church functions offer alcohol, but sometimes forget we are to offer alternatives that are as pleasing. Just being aware that there are many in our pews that are in recovery and would find it a comfort to be included in these gatherings with other options instead of having to bring your own bottle of soda to a church function. We friends of Bill have met each other this way walking into a church dinner with our bottle of coke. Although it is a great way to meet, it is much more loving and considerate to have non-alcoholic options. As we as a church struggle with what is the correct protocol about alcohol in our churches our parishioners are battling a serious disease. I want to see the day where the spirituality of AA moves out of the basements of our churches and into the sanctuary and were our sanctuaries move into our basements sharing God’s love. Its not either/or it is both/and. That looks like a win/win to me!

Lee Ann Walling

I find this post troubling. Maybe it is my Southern Baptist-turned-Episcopalian upbringing. Calling alcohol a part of our “ethos” is saying it is part of our character and core values. Really, that is the message we want to send about ourselves? We welcome people in recovery. We should be empathetic to that.

I drink – I don’t need to drink at church events. I think there can be thoughtful reaction, and if the Heather Cook tragedy doesn’t compel us to pray, ask and live into some deep questions, then we are not a very discerning or prayerful denomination. I read a comment by a candidate for Executive Council making a joke about General Convention and “Whiskeypalians.” It’s not funny.

David Streever

Isn’t alcohol part of our character? It was the predominant drink for much of our history, and Jesus serves it at the Last Supper. I don’t think many people *need* to drink at Church events, but isn’t it better to drink responsibly and healthily in order to model a healthy relationship with alcohol?

I wonder if we’re really helping anyone by drinking only in private, or hiding it?

Nancy Myron

I don’t understand how the subject of alcohol and its use/abuse is a “sudden self-consciousness” in the church. My father was an Episcopal priest who never was able to find the spirituality of recovery, and alcoholism killed him 37 years ago. At that time, the Episcopal Diocese of Michigan formed a commission to examine the problems faced by alcoholics in the church, and to form a policy of there always being a choice of beverages at both the parish and diocesan level.

Kristen Filipic

What does “welcoming the bad” mean?

I have no problem with alcohol per se. And we aren’t from a temperance tradition. But from what I’ve seen (which may not be representational) many Episcopal communities have a lot more alcohol flowing around a lot more often than I’ve seen at other churches before.

This isn’t inherently terrible. I drink myself. But when I’m in situations where groups of parishioners are telling parts of their stories, I’ve repeatedly heard people talking about coming to church as part of beginning recovery. And I look around at how much alcohol we have flowing around. And I wonder if we’re making it harder. Because making that harder seems like something I would not want to do.

Phillip Cato

This is a solid, common sense response to all the sudden self-consciousness of the Episcopal Church over its use of alcohol. Reactivity is seldom, if ever, constructive. This is a very welcome commentary by a mature priest.

Support the Café
Past Posts

The Episcopal Café seeks to be an independent voice, reporting and reflecting on the Episcopal Church and the Anglican tradition.  The Café is not a platform of advocacy, but it does aim to tell the story of the church from the perspective of Progressive Christianity.  Our collective sympathy, as the Café, lies with the project of widening the circle of inclusion within the church and empowering all the baptized for the role to which they have been called as followers of Christ.

The opinions expressed at the Café are those of individual contributors, and, unless otherwise noted, should not be interpreted as official statements of a parish, diocese or other organization. The art and articles that appear here remain the property of their creators.

All Content  © 2017 Episcopal Café