Support the Café

Search our Site

Mainstream religious leaders voice support for contraception coverage

Mainstream religious leaders voice support for contraception coverage

The Religious Institute features the statement by twenty-three major mainstream religious leaders in support of the Department of Health and Human Services that contraception services must be covered by most health insurances.

Together, the leaders of these Christian, Jewish and Muslim national organizations affirmed:

“We stand with President Obama and Secretary Sebelius in their decision to reaffirm the importance of contraceptive services as essential preventive care for women under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, and to assure access under the law to American women, regardless of religious affiliation. We respect individuals’ moral agency to make decisions about their sexuality and reproductive health without governmental interference or legal restrictions. We do not believe that specific religious doctrine belongs in health care reform – as we value our nation’s commitment to church-state separation. We believe that women and men have the right to decide whether or not to apply the principles of their faith to family planning decisions, and to do so they must have access to services. The Administration was correct in requiring institutions that do not have purely sectarian goals to offer comprehensive preventive health care. Our leaders have the responsibility to safeguard individual religious liberty and to help improve the health of women, their children, and families. Hospitals and universities across the religious spectrum have an obligation to assure that individuals’ conscience and decisions are respected and that their students and employees have access to this basic health care service. We invite other religious leaders to speak out with us for universal coverage of contraception.”

Signers include The Very Reverend Dr. Katherine Hancock Ragsdale, President of The Episcopal Divinity School, and The Rev. Dr. Elizabeth Kaeton, Convener of the Episcopal Women’s Caucus. The Episcopal Church is also part of the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice.


Café Comments?

Our comment policy requires that you use your real first and last names and provide an email address (your email will not be published). Comments that use non-PG rated language, include personal attacks, that are not provable as fact or that we deem in any way to be counter to our mission of fostering respectful dialogue will not be posted.

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
barbara snyder

Ethics that are CONTIGENT aren’t ethics at all!

Exactly. So how can an organization that is stringently pro-life be compelled to provide the morning-after pill for its employees? I mean, they’ve left abortion out of the Health Care Plan for this very reason, too; why this is so different, I really don’t understand.

The fact is that the church ISN’T “a business like any other” – even other nonprofits. As I said, the thing that makes a church a church is its “beliefs” – so I’m not sure why you’re arguing that these should have no bearing on its actions.

Church-run hospitals are part of the ministry of that church; they just aren’t comparable to jewelry stores – or fundraising organizations. No fund-raising organization has special protections built into the Bill of Rights, either: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof….”

So, yes: I’m in favor of allowing reasonable exclusions so that the Church won’t have to violate its own basic beliefs, in its own ministries. Especially on “big questions,” and especially when, as we’ve just seen, it’s not very difficult to do this.


I don’t think you’re really addressing my points, Barbara. Large not-for-profits have all the State involvement and complexities that for-profits do—if not moreso.

Should EVERYONE who works at a nonprof be subject to ***The Boss’s*** ethical belief-system?

I see this as a *workers rights* issue first, a *women’s rights* issue second, and a Church/State involvement issue third.

What I *don’t* see it as, is a “Let’s privilege Vatican ethics FIRST” issue (as if, “If we don’t let RC hospitals have their way re contraception, they won’t treat indigent patients.” Ethics that are CONTIGENT aren’t ethics at all!)

Will it decide what universities can and cannot teach, for instance?

Nevermind universities, there are public schools! Have you not noticed the Creationism controversies of the last 20+ years?

ANY school, any level, that receives PUBLIC tax $ (as most if not all “private” universities do) ABSOLUTELY should be held to *certification* requirements. If your Biology department teaches Creationism, then you should be denied certification.

As they say, this ain’t brain surgery. [But don’t you want your brain surgeon certified, by State *scientific* standards? :-X]

JC Fisher

barbara snyder

(Of course, the hospitals could just shut down, and avoid the issue that way. There are, apparently, 600+ Catholic hospitals in the country.

Or, maybe, they could stop providing prescription drug coverage at all (not sure if this is an option, though) – but they don’t want to do this, either.

It will definitely be interesting to see how this all works itself out. Perhaps a compromise can be for the hospitals to increase all employees ‘ salaries by the cost of contraception….)

barbara snyder

The hospitals are run by the Church – which by definition operates according to a set of beliefs. They are UNLIKE the businesses you mention in that they are not operating on the profit motive. They also offer their product free to people who can’t afford it -also very unlike any other sort of business. So I don’t think that particular argument holds.

I understand they’ll also be required to pay for an abortifactant drug. Are you really surprised that they object to that?

I ‘m actually rather happy there’s a group of people who think their own beliefs are more important than those of the State. They are like conscientious objectors in wartime, so I’ll offer that as my own “slippery slope ” argument: who can know what the State will get up to next? Will it decide what universities can and cannot teach, for instance?


The way this debate has been framed in the media has been driving me NUTS.

It OUGHT not be “Obama’s making religious institutions violate their consciences!”, but “HOW LARGE A CARVE-OUT to equal health care coverage for women shall we endure?”

Under the “Obamacare” provisions, religious groups (churches, temples, mosques and such) receive this exemption (which is already more than 28 states grant!).

If it’s granted to hospitals and universities (because they have the “Catholic” or “St Joseph’s” etc brandname on them), then why not to Dagostino’s Market or Murphy’s Pub? If employed by Meyer Jewelers, should THEY be able to say “You can’t get covered for a pig-ingredient heart valve”? Etc, etc, etc?

Where does it end? Will EVERYONE be at the mercy of the belief-system of their boss?! [And what if the next “conscientious objection” is to minimum wage laws?]

Hospitals and schools are BUSINESSES. They have business licenses, and state certifications.

They should comply w/ health care laws, too! “Equal Protection Under the Law”

JC Fisher

Support the Café
Past Posts

The Episcopal Café seeks to be an independent voice, reporting and reflecting on the Episcopal Church and the Anglican tradition.  The Café is not a platform of advocacy, but it does aim to tell the story of the church from the perspective of Progressive Christianity.  Our collective sympathy, as the Café, lies with the project of widening the circle of inclusion within the church and empowering all the baptized for the role to which they have been called as followers of Christ.

The opinions expressed at the Café are those of individual contributors, and, unless otherwise noted, should not be interpreted as official statements of a parish, diocese or other organization. The art and articles that appear here remain the property of their creators.

All Content  © 2017 Episcopal Café