Hiltz asks Venables to please stay home

by

Facebooktwittergoogle_pluspinterestlinkedinmail

Archbishop Fred Hiltz, Primate of the Anglican Church of Canada, has written to Presiding Bishop Gregory Venables, Primate of the Southern Cone, asking him to cancel a planned, unauthorized visit to Canada.

The Anglican Church of Canada has posted the text of the letter below:

April 21,2008

The Most Revd Gregory James Venables

Rioja 2995,1636 Olivos,

Province of Buenos Aires,

B1636DMG , Argentina

My Brother in Christ:

In this Easter Season I greet you in the name of our risen Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.

It has come to my attention that you will be participating in the Anglican Network in Canada conference, “Compelled by Christ’s Love” taking place in Vancouver, B.C., April 25-26,2008. Your visit to Canada is without any reference to or consent from my office or that of the Bishop of the Diocese of New Westminster. This represents a breach in what is considered normative in protocol among Primates and Bishops throughout the Communion.

I brought this matter before the House of Bishops meeting in Niagara Falls, Ont., last week. While we recognized that your motivation may be pastoral, there was a strong consensus that your visit at this time will further harm the strained relations between the Anglican Church of Canada and the Anglican Network in Canada.

The Bishops believe that we have made adequate and appropriate provision for the pastoral care and Episcopal support of all members of the Anglican Church of Canada, including those who find themselves in consciousness disagreement with the view of their Bishop and Synod over matters of human sexuality. This provision known as Shared Episcopal Ministry was approved by the House of Bishops in November 2004 and commended, in September 2006, by an international Panel of Reference appointed by the Archbishop of Canterbury. With this provision in place we believe there is no need for pastoral interventions by Primates or Bishops from jurisdictions outside of the Anglican Church of Canada. In fact such interventions are inappropriate. The Archbishop of Canterbury in a recent letter to me which was made public said he cannot “support or sanction” such actions.

I would also add that in a letter earlier this year to one of our Diocesan Bishops Archbishop Rowan Williams stated, “I am quite content to repeat that I do not endorse any cross-provincial transfers of allegiance, and that his office and that of the Anglican Communion recognize one ecclesial body in Canada as a constitutive member of the Communion, the Anglican Church of Canada.”

Representing a Province in communion with yours and all others in the world wide Anglican Communion I ask you as a brother Primate to stop interfering in the life of this province. This request is made in the interest of upholding the bonds of affection, and respecting catholic collegiality and provincial autonomy. I believe it is consistent with the ancient canons of the Church, and statements from successive Lambeth Conferences and the Windsor Report. It is also consistent with the commitment that all the Primates, including you, made through the communiqué from the meeting in Dromantine in 2005. That commitment stated that the Primates will, “neither encourage nor initiate cross-boundary interventions.” This commitment was repeated in the communiqué from the Primates’ Meeting in Tanzania in 2007.In light of these commitments, made by you and your fellow Primates I specifically request that you cancel your visit to Canada.

I make this request with strong support from the House of Bishops. We believe it is in accord with the action of our recent General Synod (June 2007) in support of the Windsor Report. Our resolution made particular reference to that part of the report calling “upon those Archbishops and other Bishops who believe that it is their conscientious duty to intervene in Provinces, dioceses and parishes other than their own to implement paragraph 155 of the Windsor Report and to seek an accommodation with the Bishops of the dioceses whose parishes they have taken into their own care.”

As I said in my Jan. 9, 2008 letter to all the Primates I am convinced that Canadian Anglicans are very committed to the highest degree of Communion possible in our life in Christ at home and throughout the world. Even as we grieve the breakdown of relationships within the Body of Christ (I Corinthians 12:12-26) we are committed to prayer for reconciliation one with another in Christ.

I hope you will prayerful consider and gracefully honour my request.

In Him I am

Sincerely yours

The Most Reverend Fred J. Hiltz,

Archbishop and Primate

The Anglican Church of Canada

Cc: The Archbishop of Canterbury

The Primates and Moderators of the United Churches of the Anglican Communion

Hiltz wrote the letter after consulting with the House of Bishops of the Anglican Church of Canada.

Read the letter here.

UPDATE: 7 p.m.

From the Anglican Journal:

Archbishop Venables, reached by telephone in Buenos Aires, where the province is based, said he did not intend to cancel his visit. “I don’t see any reason to call off the trip. I was invited to share with people who have already separated from the Canadian church. I wouldn’t have done anything had they not already separated,” he said.

UPDATE 10:30 p.m. – Globe and Mail

Leaders of the Anglican Church in Canada and South America drew beads on each other yesterday with Canadian primate Fred Hiltz posting a letter on the Internet telling South America’s Gregory Venables to stay out of the country and Archbishop Venables icily criticizing Archbishop Hiltz’s manners in reply.

“My number is there on the Anglican Communion network,” Archbishop Venables said in a telephone interview from Buenos Aires. “I mean, this is only my humble opinion, but if somebody really wants to talk to me, they can pick up the phone and talk to me.”

National Post Archbishop Venables Monday questioned the timing of the request.

“If I wanted to discourage somebody from coming I wouldn’t send a letter 12 hours before they get on an airplane,” he said from Buenos Aires. “The trip has been planned a long time, it’s not a secret. Is [the letter] a publicity stunt? Is it some strange way of playing a game? It was a strange experience to read a personal letter on the Internet before it came to my e-mail address.”

Archdeacon Paul Feheley, principal secretary to Archbishop Hiltz, said the letter was e-mailed to Archbishop Venables Monday, two hours before being released publicly, and that it was sent at the earliest possible time.

Dislike (0)
2 Responses to "Hiltz asks Venables to please stay home"
  1. What a good, well-reasoned letter from Archbishop Hitz. I'm glad he can offer such clear and simple words from Rowan Williams.

    Meanwhile, whatever he intends, Archbishop Venables declares his followers, 'people who have already separated from the Canadian church,' schismatic.

    Like (0)
    Dislike (0)
  2. I doubt and Anglican Covenant would have helped in this case either.

    Like (0)
    Dislike (0)