Support the Café

Search our Site

Have we forgotten how to call young people

Have we forgotten how to call young people

Over at the Lutheran, the magazine of our communion partner, the ELCA; they’re asking “Has God forgotten how to call young people?”

Drawing on research by the Pew Research Center, the article states;

29 percent of millennials (ages 18-33) aren’t affiliated with any religion and the rate of atheism in this group is twice as high as any other generation in America. Why? David Kinnaman, author of You Lost Me (Baker Books, 2011), suggests millennials are leaving the church because they experience it as overprotective, shallow, anti-science, simplistic toward sex, exclusive and unwilling to provide room for doubt.

But the ELCA should be a mecca for young people. We have a complex understanding of sexuality, an open view of Christianity, we provide room for doubt and promote scientific exploration. So why are our young people leaving?

The same question applies to the Episcopal Church; the average age of our membership is 57 and the Church Pension Group’s Report on the Clergy noted that

“The age distribution of clergy has changed drastically over time, with fewer clergy being ordained at younger ages and more clergy with older ages at ordination.” The current average age at ordination is 44, and out of over 13,000 clergy, only 624 of which are under the age of 40.

The Lutheran editorial posits it’s an issue of courage

Millennials are afraid to be Christian. It’s safe to join the Peace Corps, run a race that raises money for the poor, occupy Wall Street or make the world awesome by being a “nerdfighter.” It is not safe to be a Jesus follower.

But also, they suggest it is a lack of courage on the part of the Church;

We must be a church willing to venture into such fear and speak a word to a generation equally afraid. We must lay down our insecurities and follow our Lord who laid down his life. We must “not be ashamed of the gospel”


Does that sound right? Is the prevailing cultural image of Christianity overwhelming our witness? Does the issue lie with the Church mainly or elsewhere?


Café Comments?

Our comment policy requires that you use your real first and last names and provide an email address (your email will not be published). Comments that use non-PG rated language, include personal attacks, that are not provable as fact or that we deem in any way to be counter to our mission of fostering respectful dialogue will not be posted.

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Wayne Sherrer

As I see it, the “call” of the original article was not to ordination but to a life of faith and to participation in the faith community. Pastor Lackey, the campus pastor who authored the article, pointed to the high percentage of millennials unaffiliated with any religion, to church workers who “write off students as too busy or uninterested in faith” and to clergy who rarely “seek out those no longer attending or who’ve never been inside a church.” In fear of saying the “wrong” things to young people (and to others, I would add) we too often say nothing to people outside the walls of our church buildings about the Good News we know and so, we call no one. Yes, there is a risk (at first) of being identified with the fundamentalists when we talk to friends about our faith, but when we never mention faith, those friends are left with no alternatives to fundamentalism except atheism or “spiritual, but not religious.” Telepathy is even less effective in evangelism than it is in marriage. A parish may welcome the adventurous who risk entering its doors, but few are willing to do that without the knowledge that a familiar face will be present. People, young or old, respond most favorably to a call from someone they know. It is not enough for thousands of tongues to sing our great Redeemer’s praise inside church walls, those tongues are also needed to tell to all the world, even to our next door neighbors, that God is love.

Brad Ley

This is interesting to ponder, but it may also be a red herring…particularly in a denomination where clergy are traditionally referred to as “father.” It’s good to have clergy with life experience. It’s a strength, not a weakness, and we do it well.

We should embrace it. Agree and amplify: “Our average age of ordination is 46. Our clergy have life experience that equips them to respond to a variety of needs and situations.”

Philip B. Spivey

I have a particular interest in seeing young people consider ordained ministry, too. But like Paul Martin, I see tremendous obstacles today.

The first concerns the orientation of the millennial and X-generation members: American institutions, perse, are an anathema to many of them. The Church, as one of our oldest existing institutions, does not escape their scrutiny. I think it is fare to say that TEC has distinguished itself by taking-on humanity-affirming issues over time that others domains of Christianity have not. However, when our young adults look at the whole of Christianity, no such distinctions are made. Christianity and frequently all organized religions, are dismissed with the same brush. When (if you can believe it) Public Service Broadcasting and its featured PBS NewsHour are among the most trusted American institutions, you know we have a problem. To bear this out,in our most recent election cycle, polls reported that the youth and young adults stayed home in large numbers. In these very critical times I must ask, how alienated can they be?

Secondly, part of that alienation stems from tradition of the Church. In generations gone by, future clergy were hand-picked by some priest or bishop and sent off to seminary. In those days, somehow an aspirant could afford the journey to priesthood. In those days, it was white males who were chosen to serve. In 2014, although some racial, gender and country-of-origin barriers have been lifted, the costs of formation have skyrocketed and again, some in the Church find themselves face with economic barriers.

Finally, I don’t think we’ve forgotten how to call young people. I don’t we’ve given them the resources to be called—by God. Discerning God’s purpose for us should begin at any early age; not the discernment for the ministry, but discernment for God’s call—whatever that might be. We’ve overvalued the discernment for ministry (because really, how many of us are called to it?) and given short-shrift to our lay ministries, which are infinite.

Paul Martin

I am hardly an expert, but there are some issues which I cannot let go of.

First, the world is changing. It is changing more rapidly than ever before, and so is the community and the generation we are trying to address. We have made multiple changes in the prayer book and hymnal over the years to deal with changes in the English language. The process is too slow, too difficult, but our practice changes anyway. I hear a service with subtle changes to accept women, to avoid hurting them. We have to find a way to adapt to the next generation, to express a message that makes sense to a changing world around us.

Second, who is communicating to the community at large? A few months ago, I heard a commercial from a college. It sounded like a very good pitch until I heard the phrase, “Christian College.” I am amazed by how quickly that phrase turned me off. I am a Christian. I have been an Episcopalian for all my life. And yet, the term “Christian” has a tendency to generate the image of a Southern Baptist, or other churches in that part of the Christian Community. These are the people who use that word; and I guess we don’t. This determines how the word is defined in many minds, even mine. We need a way to communicate who we are, using both the similarities and the differences with those who dominate the television ads.

Third, we must listen. I see no other way to understand the changes we need to make. When I was in college, Constance Parvey (ELCA) was very skilled in providing a place where she would listen to us. It was an experience of growth, and our relationship to the church grew as well. Graduate school and an Episcopal church right on campus was very similar. Are we surveying campus churches for their input? Are we asking churches generally for their experience with the younger people?

William Hammond

The article says that less than half of one percent of our clergy are under 40. (Is it correct?) That’s not a good thing.

But don’t we, these days, generally tell young people in college who are interested in seminary that first they should gain experience working in the world?

Support the Café
Past Posts

The Episcopal Café seeks to be an independent voice, reporting and reflecting on the Episcopal Church and the Anglican tradition.  The Café is not a platform of advocacy, but it does aim to tell the story of the church from the perspective of Progressive Christianity.  Our collective sympathy, as the Café, lies with the project of widening the circle of inclusion within the church and empowering all the baptized for the role to which they have been called as followers of Christ.

The opinions expressed at the Café are those of individual contributors, and, unless otherwise noted, should not be interpreted as official statements of a parish, diocese or other organization. The art and articles that appear here remain the property of their creators.

All Content  © 2017 Episcopal Café