Support the Café

Search our Site

Glasgow cathedral receives threats after Qur’an readings

Glasgow cathedral receives threats after Qur’an readings

Provost Kelvin Holdsworth reflects on the response he and the congregation of St. Mary’s Cathedral received after their Epiphany celebration. where a portion of the Qur’an was read.

What’s in Kelvin’s Head?:

And so last week as we were reflecting on the arrival of the mysterious Magi at Bethlehem we again asked local Muslim friends if they would like to be present. Again there was a recitation and again there was a huge amount of interest amongst those present. The gospel was proclaimed, the preacher preached and the Eucharist was celebrated. Our Muslim friends were interested in what we do and had a number of questions afterwards. There was particular interest amongst the musicians as to the way arabic recitation works and one or two technical conversations about similarities between psalm pointing and Qur’anic recitation.

It was regarded locally as a good event – the kind of thing that St Mary’s does well. We’re pretty strong on midweek festivals and I always feel a joy at being able to get over a hundred people out for a midweek choral mass.

Having a recitation from the Qur’an in a Christian cathedral in worship is not a new thing. I’m aware of a time in the early 1990s when St Giles’s Cathedral in Edinburgh (ie Church of Scotland) hosted an event at which there was Islamic prayer within the cathedral. In 1991 at St Mungo’s Cathedral there was a service at which there was a recitation from the Qur’an which involved local church leaders including Archbishop Tom Winning and the then Moderator of the Church of Scotland.

Recitations from the Qur’an in Christians worship are unusual but not unknown. I’m aware of one in Liverpool Cathedral and at other events within the Church of England at civic services and within the context of number of university chaplaincies. No-one pretends that Muslims and Christians believe the same things. We know that Muslims don’t believe in the divinity of Christ – that’s a known and accepted fact. It isn’t surprising.

But how many Christians know that Muslims believe in the Virgin birth and how many have heard that from the Qur’anic tradition?

And that kind of thing is worth knowing.

So it has indeed come as something of a surprise to find accounts of last week’s service appearing online and stirring up the most most incredible pot of hatred I’ve ever encountered. (And I’m a veteran of the sex wars amongst Anglicans).

Offensive and threatening comments warranted police investigation. The Christian Post:

Offensive comments directed at clergy at St Mary’s Cathedral, Glasgow, have prompted a police investigation after the Quran was read at a service last week.

Police Scotland confirmed it is investigating remarks after the Epiphany service contained a recitation from the Islamic holy book denying Jesus was the son of God – a key Christian doctrine.

“The congregation was also reminded during the service that it is not only Christians who give honour to Jesus. We were joined by friends from two local Muslim communities.”

A video of the incident on YouTube prompted outrage from some Anglicans with calls for him to quit. The video has also been removed.

Rev James Paice, a leading member of the conservative GAFCON UK grouping, called on the Archbishop of Canterbury to intervene in an open letter to Lambeth Palace.

This came after the former Bishop of Rochester, Michael Nazir-Ali, also called for action.

“”The authorities of the Scottish Episcopal Church should immediately repudiate this ill-advised invitation,” he said in a statement.

Holdsworth reflects on how the encounters have deepened the faith of the Cathedral members:

And there are happy pics of Muslim folk in church at Christmas alongside their Christian neighbours.

This is becoming normal for us and it matters.

Frankly, we think it is a good thing that Muslims are coming to church and hearing us proclaim the Gospel of Christ.

Here in Glasgow we have our history of religious conflict. When Muslims new to the city are asked, “Aye, but are you a protestant Muslim or a catholic Muslim?” it is both funny and not so funny.

But I rejoice in the fact that at least sometimes our interfaith encounters are real and life changing.

The truth is, people confident in their faith can often learn most from one another. We are confident in our Christian faith and enjoy sharing it.

The photo is posted on Pinterest by Edinburgh Pride.


Café Comments?

Our comment policy requires that you use your real first and last names and provide an email address (your email will not be published). Comments that use non-PG rated language, include personal attacks, that are not provable as fact or that we deem in any way to be counter to our mission of fostering respectful dialogue will not be posted.

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Aaron Fraustro

The recitation from the Quran denies Christ’s divinity and calls the belief blasphemous. It is for this belief that so many Christians have been persecuted. It is the core of the Christian faith. It does not strike as me as odd that this passage was spoken or that Episcopalians did not see a problem with it. So many deny Christ as the Son of God. The Episcopal Church is not Christian so much at is Unitarian Universalist.

Rod Gillis

Language games, with loaded terms and the assigning of explanations to a group one does not belong to, tend to mitigate against genuine dialogue.

Robert Martin

Its surprising that many Anglicans don’t see the connection between having Muslims in your church reciting passages denying Christ, and the drop off in Anglicans attending Church and Christians proclaiming themselves Anglicans.

There is a time and a place for everything. Reconciliation does not mean self denial and Christ denial. Perhaps some clerics just get bored and like to see the kerfluffle ensuing when they “transgress/reach out/radically welcome” the other who denies Christ.

It’s very sad to see what has become of this once mighty Church.

Rod Gillis

Peter denied Christ, having first confessed him as The Christ.

However, Muslims accept him as a prophet, so describing their position as a “denial” is a rather unfortunate and loaded way to assign a particular position to Muslims.

Declining attendance has nothing to do with Muslims and everything to do with Christians who have simply come to the conclusion they can no longer with integrity accept the doctrinal positions of whatever church they previously confessed, and have opted instead for some form or other of secularism.

The Reverend Nola Crewe

What a brilliant idea . . . my congratulations to your rector and I shall take advantage of this example in some service in the not distant future. As I regularly remind my congregation: three faiths claim Abraham. While we use the Old Testament in every service, the third faith’s interpretation of our mutual history is clearly different. We all benefit when we know more of other faiths and why they believe what they believe. God bless, St Monica’s Anglican Church, Toronto, Canada

David Allen

A reader has reported on our Facebook page’s posting of this same story, that another Episcopal cathedral had the same Quranic passage entoned this Christmas season as well, but this time it was on Christmas Eve. The reading was sung at Grace Cathedral in San Francisco and was well & widely received.

Allie Chapin-haight

I read with interest the article about the fallout of having a young Muslim read from the Quran during an interfaith service st St. Mary’s Cathedral. It is with grief I read there has been an abusive response and there might be disciplinary action taken. That an effort of inclusiveness, peace and tolerance should be punished is in opposition to Christian values. One God, omnipresent and omnipotent, has taken His way to love, instruct and support all His children, and what man or what group should decide they have exclusivity and the justification to reject any teaching that deviates from what he or they personally choose, or to punish in any way another or others who in basic have belief and faith in the one God. Because a youngster stated in a service he honors Jesus as a profit rather than a son, this deserves punishment, for any one? Muslims and Christians believe alike in God, who shall take God’s hand away from anyone? The church should loudly claim it’s support for all those involved in such a wonderful gesture of understanding, promotion of peace and goodwill that this interfaith service was engaged in.

Support the Café
Past Posts

The Episcopal Café seeks to be an independent voice, reporting and reflecting on the Episcopal Church and the Anglican tradition.  The Café is not a platform of advocacy, but it does aim to tell the story of the church from the perspective of Progressive Christianity.  Our collective sympathy, as the Café, lies with the project of widening the circle of inclusion within the church and empowering all the baptized for the role to which they have been called as followers of Christ.

The opinions expressed at the Café are those of individual contributors, and, unless otherwise noted, should not be interpreted as official statements of a parish, diocese or other organization. The art and articles that appear here remain the property of their creators.

All Content  © 2017 Episcopal Café