Support the Café

Search our Site

Election 2016 responses

Election 2016 responses

Reactions to the election news from around the church and communion continue to appear.  There is lament but hope as well and determination to hold fast to faith and to continue the work of the Gospel.


Presiding Bishop Michael Curry has offered his thoughts in a video here.


Nurya Love Parish, who blogs at Churchwork writes;

Today I will tell my children that history has its wrinkles, but God triumphs in the end. I will send them into the world to be disciples of Jesus Christ today just as they were yesterday and I pray they will be tomorrow.

Disciples of Jesus Christ know something about betrayal, sin, and brokenness.

Disciples of Jesus Christ know that none of these are the last word.

My prayer today, and for the years to come (not just four, because the consequences of this presidency will last much longer than four years), is simply that God would show me the path to take as a disciple of Jesus to live up to these words:

Beloved, let us love one another, because love is from God; everyone who loves is born of God and knows God. Whoever does not love does not know God, for God is love.

I am going to love my whole country. I am going to love my neighbors with whom I profoundly disagree, whose votes I believe have cast the shadow of (self-)destruction over our nation and this fragile earth, our island home.

I am going to be honest, because that is what love does.


Sam Candler, Dean of the Cathedral of St Philip in Atlanta, GA at his blog, Good Faith and the Common Good wonders about how the power of feelings drove this campaign in unprecedented ways;

“I could not believe how little substance mattered in this presidential campaign. I believe Donald Trump is our president-elect because he tapped into our country’s latent feelings of anger and loss, fear and dis-respect. Many of us Americans do feel those things, and some of us felt we had no other way to express those feelings except with a vote. Trump appealed to our inner anger and frustration, even to our envy and jealousy that –no matter who we are, rich or poor—things do not always go our way. Sufficient evidence or consistent substance were not necessary.

In an opposite way, the candidacy of Hillary Clinton seemed unable to tap into any feelings at all. She was often characterized as aloof and unapproachable. Again, the substance of what she was offering the country seemed to matter only secondarily to the way people felt. She seemed the most free and available a few days before the election when the rain began to pour during her speech. With wet hair and clothes, she raised her hands in a most emotionally available way; it was unusual. People just didn’t like her, in much the same degree that people just didn’t like Donald Trump.”


The Rev. Dr. Victoria Weinstein, who blogs at Peacebang reminds her readers that their is still important work to be done and neighbor’s to be served in Christ’s name:

Do justice. Love mercy. Walk humbly with our God. Walk fiercely with our Muslim neighbor, our Mexican neighbor (I literally have both), our sister who is unexpectedly and very unhappily pregnant. Show up fiercely for them. Keep hollering that black lives matter and that “all lives matter” is a sorry rejoinder to that necessary cry of resistance. Keep studying, writing, and witnessing. Feed the hungry. Mobilize your communities. Work hard at keeping networks strong. Worship mightily.


The Archbishop of Canterbury, Justin Welby also offered prayers for healing and for wisdom on the part of the President-elect;

“As President-elect Donald Trump prepares to take office, my continuing prayers are that the United States of America may find reconciliation after a bitter campaign, and that Mr Trump may be given wisdom, insight and grace as he faces the tasks before him. Together we pray for all the people of the United States.”


Also from the United Kingdom, Kelvin Holdsworth, Provost of St Mary’s Cathedral in Glasgow, Scotland has a blog post titled; “The Trump of Judgment for Liberals.”  He sees the election as a repudiation of the values that have guided the US and it’s allies since the end of the Second World War

“The true enormity of the defeat of Hilary Clinton has to be faced head on. I’m sorry for Hilary Clinton but this isn’t merely a personal defeat. It is a defeat of a whole set of liberal values that millions of us hold throughout the world. If we want to know where to go next with those values there are some tough truths that we need to face.

  • Donald Trump didn’t win the election despite being a xenophobe. He won it because he was a xenophobe.
  • Donald Trump didn’t win the election despite being sexist. He won it because he was sexist.
  • Donald Trump didn’t win the election despite being anti-LGBT. He won it because he was anti-LGBT.
  • Donald Trump didn’t win the election despite being unqualified for office. He won it because he was unqualified for office.
  • Donald Trump didn’t win the election despite being against every progressive value people like me hold. He won it because he was.”

And he reminds us that the real fear and anxiety felt by so rarely results in a turn towards liberalism; that fear breeds insularity

“And one of the things that is wrong with the world is the presumption on the part of so many of us who hold liberal views that if things get more difficult for people then those same people will automatically turn with joy and thanksgiving to the solutions of the liberal-left. The reality is far from that. People who are frightened for themselves more often turn to the right.

This election result is a trump of judgement for those of us who are liberals. The #Brexit result was another such trump but I fear neither will be the last.”


And Peter Carrel, the New Zealand cleric behind Anglicans Down Under thinks that the election of Trump is divine punishment for Reality TV and other less-than-savory aspects of American culture (things can look different from far away)

For an America which has given itself over to the debauchery and quackery (reality TV) which passes for Hollywood entertainment, which has rorted the political and financial systems in favour of the 1%, and more recently doubled down its relentless critique of the Christian gospel, God has given them up in this election to the perfect expression of 21st century American culture.

The rest of the world is under this judgment too, the pain of it almost certainly to be felt in economic strife and stress, if not in many more wars or even one big WW3.


And our Cafe editor, Jon White, posted an opinion piece this morning where he named his lament, but also trust in the rhythms of the life of faith to carry us through;

“My heart trusts in you.”  I know it is true, but right now my heart is sore.  I suspect it will be sore for some time yet.  While my brain reels and my heart grieves though I know that I can trust in the rhythms of the life of faith to carry me through.  “You are the strength of your people, a safe refuge for your anointed,” the psalmist writes.  For me I know that is true.  There is solace in the rounds of daily prayer and scripture, the resilience of the prayer book will be sufficient while my own ebbs at low tide.

but ultimately, Christian faith is the proclamation of hope against the insistent murmur of fear;

We too have our part and our portion of the work; to live in the kingdom of God even while all the evidence points to the folly of doing so.



What other voices are you hearing?  Please share in the comments


Café Comments?

Our comment policy requires that you use your real first and last names and provide an email address (your email will not be published). Comments that use non-PG rated language, include personal attacks, that are not provable as fact or that we deem in any way to be counter to our mission of fostering respectful dialogue will not be posted.

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Prof Christopher Seitz

1. Health care for a family of 4 under the ACA is running at the rate of a mortgage on a 600K house.

2. Watching an older man be beaten for five minutes as he struggled to get to his car — because he apparently did not vote for Clinton — made for sobering viewing this morning. Portland Oregon facing riots and destruction.

More generally, is it no longer possible to lose? A race, a vote, a test, a hard challenge, a contest? This is or ought to be in that book about things we learned in kindergarten to which the PB referred.

Kenneth Knapp

It would seem that we have allowed politics to divide the church.

JC Fisher

Circular firing squad, assemble!

I’m once again struck w/ the truth of Will Rogers famous aphorism, “I’m not a member of an organized political party: I’m a Democrat.” One wonders if Hillbots and BernieBros will still be at each other’s throats, by the time we’re BOTH shipped off to camps in the United States of Trump. [Yes, that’s hyperbole…for now. Kyrie eleison!]

Paul Woodrum

Probably no civil war, but I bet a great recession will once again devour the land before four years is up.

Cynthia Katsarelis

I think the frustration of the working class has much to do with 1. obstruction by the GOP these last 8 years.
2. The “bait and switch” that GOP elite did to the working class for the decades of the culture wars (elite didn’t care about abortion and gays, that was bait). The working class suddenly figured out that the elite’s trickle down economics wasn’t reaching them, and they decided to blame the black president, gays, immigrants, Muslims…
3. They got left behind in the post industrial society, ushered in by Reagan, with no safety net to help them adapt.
4. The rural situation.
5. Identity politics surrounding all of the above.

The anger and fear came to a boil.

Could the Democrats have done better at responding to their needs? No doubt, but the obstacles were huge.

So somehow, I now have to worry about my human rights as a gay person, all women have to deal with the grave situation of having a sexual predator be affirmed by half of the voting population, and people of color, especially immigrants, have to worry about vicious attacks and whether they can keep their families together.

Jesus tells us that we’ll know them by their fruits. So far, it’s dreadful.

Support the Café
Past Posts

The Episcopal Café seeks to be an independent voice, reporting and reflecting on the Episcopal Church and the Anglican tradition.  The Café is not a platform of advocacy, but it does aim to tell the story of the church from the perspective of Progressive Christianity.  Our collective sympathy, as the Café, lies with the project of widening the circle of inclusion within the church and empowering all the baptized for the role to which they have been called as followers of Christ.

The opinions expressed at the Café are those of individual contributors, and, unless otherwise noted, should not be interpreted as official statements of a parish, diocese or other organization. The art and articles that appear here remain the property of their creators.

All Content  © 2017 Episcopal Café