Playing with creation

Spore is a new video game, created by the same fellow behind the virtual world phenom "The Sims." This time, he's taken that virtual world experience to a new level--one that begins when a virtual comet slams into a primordial virtual world, giving a player the virtual building blocks to start from single-celled scratch.

Time Magazine makes note of the game in last week's issue:

God rested after he created life, but you're just getting started. Next you shepherd your fledgling life-form through its single-celled stage until it's ready to crawl onto land, at which time you decide where its various eyes and ears and limbs and less easily identifiable appendages go. Then it must learn to feed itself and reproduce. Eventually, it forms tribes and builds cities. Finally it achieves spaceflight, whereupon you guide it off into the galaxy to meet other sentient species.

You can't turn the entire history of life into a video game without wrestling with some heavy philosophical questions, but Wright seems to have steered a middle course that avoids both religious and evolutionary blasphemy. You could read Spore equally easily as a model of evolution or of intelligent design, with you in the role of Intelligent Designer. (O.K., it's a bit blasphemous.) "A game like this can actually generate interesting, meaningful conversations between people," Wright says. "I think that's the best thing it can do."

That's an interesting point on its own, but wait! There's more! First on the conversation block? Antispore.com, a site run by a segment of Christians who object not to the blasphemy (O.K., perhaps a bit) but more to the notion that it "teaches" evolutionary theory and undermines creationism, whatever it represents as a potential metaphor for intelligent design.

(It bears noting an interesting potential sidebar conversation, there: can video games make great teaching tools?)

PC News points to the review calling it "well good" entertainment in icily wry fashion. A short excerpt shows the real problem they have with the games creator, though, whom Time says describes himself as "definitely an atheist. Well, agnostic atheist maybe." It's not even that he didn't immediately condemn the new art movement of "Spore-nography"—new "species" that physically resemble genitalia. Rather:

"I used to like Will Wright," continues Anti-Spore.com. "He created Sim City, a fantastic game that celebrated the earth that God created for us and allowed you to use all your God given abilities to make an ideal society. But if you ever felt like you had too much power, God would come in with a tornado or an earthquake and put you back in place.

"You would think that as a member of the Episcopal Church, a smart man like Will Wright would not be capable of creating Spore. However, we must be reminded that the Episcopal Church is the only church in america that ordains homosexuals on a regular basis.

The Time story is here, and the PC News story with a link to the Antispore site is here.

Comments (5)

...Sim City, a fantastic game that celebrated the earth that God created for us and allowed you to use all your God given abilities to make an ideal society. But if you ever felt like you had too much power, God would come in with a tornado or an earthquake and put you back in place.

So this is the orthodox theology that all right-thinking people are supposed to espouse? If so, then Hurricane Ike, like Rita and Katrina, are somehow God's way of keeping us humble. Sorry, I'd rather have someone pretend to be God in a game (yes, it is a game folks...) than have someone think that God somehow puts us "back in place" with natural disasters.

You would think that as a member of the Episcopal Church, a smart man like Will Wright would not be capable of creating Spore. However, we must be reminded that the Episcopal Church is the only church in america that ordains homosexuals on a regular basis.

Hey look, it's the all-purpose explanation for "everything we don't like": "It's 'cuz they ordain the homos."

Pathetic. (And, "a bit blasphemous")

JC Fisher

Just a note that the Anti-Spore site is a spoof.

http://antispore.com/the-real-about-page/

They may or may not believe anything they writer there, but they disclaim everything as a big joke. AS they say there,

"Episcopal Church, I think it is pretty cool that you are progressive enough to move forward and accept all types of people. I personally think that love for all humans is a key message in the bible that should be practiced by all, religious or not."

Thanks, Huw. I, was taken in by the spoof and helped propagate it.

Slate has a nice article covering on Spore and the ID/evolution sides of it:
http://www.slate.com/id/2199922/pagenum/all/#page_start

I'm totally loving Spore! Thanks for that link on Slate: I'm glad to know I'm not the only nut out there that wonders how this could be about "Godless" anything. I do recognise it's partly the fault of a game: you can't have a game without a player.

I didn't like the spoof, btw: a voice trumpeting the "all Christians have to be this stereotypically stupid" line was even more annoying when it came from a pretend Christian.

Add your comments

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Reminder: At Episcopal Café, we hope to establish an ethic of transparency by requiring all contributors and commentators to make submissions under their real names. For more details see our Feedback Policy.

Advertising Space