Flag and faith: flags in sanctuary
Vanessas Gonzalez Kraft, writing at Busted Halo, raises the issue of flags in churches
When I was a kid, I always enjoyed holding my hand over my heart and saying the Pledge of Allegiance at the beginning of the school day. I love singing the “Star-Spangled Banner” at the beginning of baseball games. My heart can’t help but swell with pride for my country. My dad, being from Mexico, always made sure I knew how blessed I was to be born and live in the United States of America.That being said, my first allegiance is to God. When it comes to “God stuff” in “State stuff,” I have no problems. I think it’s great that the Pledge of Allegiance includes “one nation under God.” I know the Knights of Columbus fought hard for this addition. It is citing the correct order of things — God first, Country second.
...
As Christians, I do believe that we are called to be patriotic and to perform our civic duty. I see nothing incompatible with a patriotic Catholic who has pride in his/her country. But in the physical space of the Mass, in that sacred place, our country is heaven and our allegiance is to God.This being a country with a very large immigrant population, I have often wondered if immigrants feel somewhat excluded when they are in Mass and see a flag up there by Jesus. Do they feel like the church is telling them that Jesus is only for the American citizens?
What do you think? Does your church have the US flag displayed? Where?

My little parish church in New York City has 2 flags, the flag of the Anglican communion and the US flag. The flags have been in the building for a very long time (though the Anglican communion flag replaced a flag of the Episcopal church when the compass rose flag became available). The flags are in the transepts, on small poles. As you sit in the nave, they aren't very visible at all. I see the US flag primarily as a monument to those many members of the congregation of died in the First and Second World Wars (and the smaller number who died in later wars) under the flag. It seems apt and fitting. I've often objected to flags that clearly competed visually with the altar (or with the pulpit), yet in my current parish, I see a way to honor the flag in the church building, while keeping the focus of eyes, hearts, and spirits where it belongs.
Posted by Dale McNeill
|
June 14, 2011 8:45 PM
My church displays the US and TEC flags. To worry over them one way or the other is a distraction. In the state where it sometimes feels like we've not gotten over the Civil War and its flag it's kinda nice the sense of the congregation (presumably) is to display the flag.
I liked the compromise my last church had: during Lent the flags went out with the flowers and banners.
Posted by John B. Chilton
|
June 14, 2011 8:58 PM
We have an American flag on the Gospel end of the altar and the Episcopal flag on the opposite end. I dislike them intensely. I'm sure many people aren't even aware of them but suspect they would be miss them if the flags disappeared. The Lutheran church I came from would never have allowed flags behind the altar rail. Good policy IMO.
Posted by Shelley Huston
|
June 14, 2011 9:02 PM
When this discussion of display of the national flag in the sanctuary comes up, I always take a little time to ponder this simple thought:
"I wonder how Jesus would have felt about having Caesar's Standard in the Temple...?"
Food for thought.
Posted by Earl Barber
|
June 14, 2011 9:13 PM
I think in that sacred space, the sanctuary, the allegiance and attention belongs to God and God's sacraments. A national banner and/or one any church except the holy catholic church (which is represented by other symbols) is distracting. That said, if there are historic or traditional reasons for a parish to discreetly display them in areas such as transepts or a narthex, I'm not as bothered.
Joe Brewer
Posted by joebrewer
|
June 14, 2011 9:28 PM
I am a veteran (US Navy, 1971-1975), but I agree with Shelley, Joe, and (I think) Earl: a US flag beside or near the altar is a distraction. That's probably a minority opinion, so we are unlikely to see a change anytime soon.
Posted by Craig Abernethy
|
June 14, 2011 9:43 PM
We have an American flag in my church as well and an Episcopal flag. Well, that's what is there when it's a church. That same space also serves as a synagogue and at those times it's the American flag and a Star of David flag. The American one rather nicely communicates that the two congregations have that in common. The flags are not near the altar.
Posted by Judy Avery
|
June 14, 2011 10:13 PM
My church (TEC) has a flagpole outside in an appropriate location for both faith and nation flags.
My mother's church (RCC) carries the nation's flag into the sanctuary only on special occasions where prayers are offered specifically for the country (such as national holidays like Memorial Day or Labor Day), for a military funeral/wedding/ceremony, or when the BSA (Boy Scouts of America) are assisting with a service in some way (which is a few times a year, as the deacon is both a scoutmaster and the troop's chaplain). And on those occasions, the flags are carried in at the start of Mass, and removed immediately after.
Both, I think, are appropriate.
Posted by Kate Jackson
|
June 14, 2011 10:22 PM
Our parish has the Episcopal Church flag and the American Flag displayed in the narthex. They used to be in the sanctuary but were moved in response to concerns about the appropriateness of their presence. This was before my I came to the parish but my impression is that we want to send the message that all are welcome, not just Americans and not just Episcopalians.
[Thank you for your comment. Our comment policy requires you include your first and last name. - ed.]
Posted by Apps 55753818692 1675970731 F785b701a6d1b8c33f0408
|
June 15, 2011 8:33 AM
My parish has the US, TEC and Anglican Communion flags all in a side chapel. The US and TEC used to fly from the rear of the church over the central doors, but the plaster was cracking and they came down to stand in the chapel. In addition, my parish has the national flags of the twenty or more countries from which members of my congregation hail, as well as the "Pride" (Rainbow) flag among them, all lining the top of the partition dividing the pews and the "narthex" (such as it is).
Posted by tobias haller
|
June 15, 2011 11:20 AM
We have an Episcopal and an American flag that hang off the balcony on the side aisles of the Church.
They seem to fit in just fine in this 200 year old Church...
Rev. Kurt Huber
St. Peter's, Monroe
Posted by Kurt Huber
|
June 15, 2011 12:20 PM
The Episocopal parish I used to attend moved the flags to the narthex, Episcopal and USA flags on each side of the door.
The one I attend now has them pretty much 'out of sight' by placing them in our 'modern' sanctuary.
By that, I mean the choir stands behind the altar, the musicians to each side. The flags are to the sides of the musicians.
In other words, they are not occupying a space that is in the visual, focal, focused range of the congregants. In fact, it is easy to NOT see the flags there.
As noted by others, I do approve of the addition of the USA flag on appropriate days of remembrance and honor for our country's servants in what they (and most of us) believe to be in the honor and purpose of our Christ.
Posted by Earl Barber
|
June 15, 2011 1:29 PM