Student expelled after sexual abuse by Episcopal teacher

The Dallas Morning News reports on the testimony in the lawsuit against Episcopal School of Dallas:


The Rev. Stephen Swann, headmaster of the Episcopal School of Dallas, told jurors Monday that he reached out to the family of a girl whose parents are suing the school for failing to protect her from a sexual relationship with a teacher.

But he said the girl’s father told him, “It’s just too late.”

Swann, wearing a clerical collar for the first time during the trial, said he told the father in a telephone conversation, “I’m so sorry that [the daughter] and your family have gone through what you’ve had to go through at the hands of Nathan Campbell. He committed a sin and I am so sorry.”
...

...The lawsuit alleges that the girl was unfairly expelled after her relationship with the teacher came to light. The relationship was discovered in fall 2009.

Swann’s phone call to the family came much later, after the lawsuit was filed. He told jurors that he stands by his decision to force the girl to withdraw after the relationship came to light because it was best for her to “get a new start.”
...
The family’s attorney, Charla Aldous, pressed Swann earlier in the day repeatedly about the school’s lack of regular employee training to recognize and report sexual abuse. “I’m convinced that the sexual abuser will do the abuse, no matter the number of times we offer that course,” Swann said.


In another case, a former Episcopal school counselor at Ascension School in Lafayette, LA was sentenced to 30 years in prison for her abuse of a student.
Hargrave, who was a counselor and yoga instructor at the school, began counseling the 14-year-old female victim during spring 2009. Haik sharply criticized Hargrave on Wednesday for taking advantage of the student, who went to Hargrave for help with depression and suicidal feelings.

"You will survive," Haik told Hargrave. "I pray to God that young lady does too."
...
"This case reflects the serious consequences and fallout of individuals who sexually abuse minors," Finley said in a news release.

"The harm done to children is long range and often irreversible. The actions of the defendant are disturbing, and the sentence is justified."

The seriousness of harm can not be underestimated in these cases. The church and its affiliated institutions needs to pay attention to the victims rather than trying to protect itself through silence. Proactive actions beyond mere "I'm sorry" (often said too late and only when forced by the courts) must be taken.

Training for all adults and youth for awareness of signs of potential abuse needs to be done frequently. Clergy, teachers and counselors should never meet alone behind closed doors with youth or adults. Incidents should be reported and investigated promptly with offers of support and therapy for victims. In the case of minors - sexual abuse must be reported immediately to law enforcement.

Those who have been victimized should be allowed to make as many choices as possible about their future to restore agency and confidence. The church cannot allow fear of lawsuits to blind it to the needs of justice.

One hopes the leaders at the Episcopal Church Center will listen.

Comments (3)

The Reverend Stephen Swann was, and quite possibly still is, in the wrong line of work. Expediency in getting rid of one student instead of properly reporting an abusive teacher whose "loss" would affect far more students and impact the school year and whose criminal actions, if publicized, would damage the school's reputation, is a false choice and a rotten decision that he was not alone in making. There have been other cases where duty to one was tossed aside in the foolish belief that "the many and the greater" benefitted from that choice.

Abuse awareness training is not to be "offered." It is to be Required. And staff must clearly understand in advance that the Inquisition has never been an Anglican or Episcopal agency, the Church does not hold "confidential" trials, nor does it grant Dispensations for sexual abuse, that it bears the heavy responsibility of Pastoral Duty which public schools do not, and that the police should and will be handling any such matter, should such a matter arise.

There is a reason that we are continually reminded to take care of the single individual, the person who may be - and for us, should be - Christ. Surely, the leadership of the Chuirch hasn't forgotten so simple and foundational a point of faith? I pray wholeheartedly that they haven't.

Rev. CW Brockenbrough

I'm speechless.

God, grant justice!

JC Fisher

Here's a question. Who gets to call themselves an Episcopal school? I notice on the Diocese of Dallas website that ESD is in the list of "independent schools". What does independent schools. Does that mean the bishop is endorsing schools over which he or she exercises no authority?

Are both sides getting something out of this relationship? EDS gets to use the Episcopal name. The diocese gets to take credit for things it has no part in.

And then when such an Episcopal school gets in trouble the reputation of The Episcopal Church is tarnished.

I would think that if you're going to use the name Episcopal there are some hoops you have to jump through. Somewhere in my memory banks I recall an accreditation group for Episcopal schools. Is it under the supervision of The Episcopal Church?

Add your comments

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Reminder: At Episcopal Café, we hope to establish an ethic of transparency by requiring all contributors and commentators to make submissions under their real names. For more details see our Feedback Policy.

Advertising Space