A Robinson invite?

Chuck Blanchard points us to Ruth Gledhill's report that it looks like Bishop Gene Robinson may well get an invite to Lambeth after all, albeit as a nonvoting member. She also asserts that Bishop Martyn Minns will not.

Gledhill was sent, apparently by a third party, a letter said to have been written by Canon Flora Winfield to those inquiring about Robinson's status. It reads:

'The Archbishop of Canterbury has asked me to thank you for your letter of 22 May 2007 regarding his invitation to bishops of the Anglican Communion to next year’s Lambeth Conference. The Archbishop is taking a period of study leave this summer and he has therefore asked me to respond to your letter on his behalf.

Prior to his departure, Archbishop Rowan noted carefully the level of disappointment expressed by correspondents, following his decision not to extend an invitation to Bishop Gene Robinson to attend the Lambeth Conference along with the other bishops. He stressed in his letter to the bishops that he did not take this decision lightly, but that he regarded it as appropriate in the light of the recommendations set out in the Windsor Report.

The Windsor Report counselled that in the future proper regard should be taken to the bounds of affection and interdependence between member Churches when considering the acceptability of a candidate for Episcopal appointment. While is it recognised that Bishop Robinson was duly elected and consecrated according to the canons of The Episcopal Church in view of the widespread objections to Bishop Robinson’s ministry in other Provinces of the Communion, the Windsor Report further recommend that the Archbishop ‘ exercise very considerable caution in inviting him to the councils of the Communion.

From the time of the election of Bishop Gene Robinson to See of New Hampshire, both the representatives of many Anglican Provinces and the Instruments of Communion made it clear that full recognition by the Communion could not be given to a bishop whose chosen lifestyle would, in most Provinces of the Communion, give rise to canonical impediment to his consecration as a bishop. The Archbishop has to be loyal to that widespread concern as well as bearing in mind the position of Bishop Robinson within The Episcopal Church. The Archbishop is therefore exploring inviting Bishop Robinson to the conference in another status.

Thank you once again for writing.'

Chuck excerpts the parts about Robinson and provides his own brief commentary here. You can also read the entire Gledhill column here.

UPDATE: Commenter Ginny Gibbs writes "Actually, the text appears identical to that of a letter I saw just last night at a parish meeting. It was written in response to a form letter a friend who's a member of Integrity had sent."

UPDATE, 29 June: The Times publishes a brief column by Gledhill making the assertion "Bishop Gene will be able to attend meetings as an official guest but will not have the right to vote on motions at the conference."

Comments (3)

My opinion is this letter means nothing. It's a rehash of what the Archbishop of Canterbury has already said about the invitations, and how Bishop Robinson might be included. I note that Gledhill is only saying "sources say"; it's not in the letter.

Indeed, it could be read to say ABC is listening even more closely to those who oppose any invitation of any kind for Robinson.

My recollection of what was publicly know at last report is that Robinson and his supporters are still lobbying for a full invitation.

Actually, the text appears identical to that of a letter I saw just last night at a parish meeting. It was written in response to a form letter a friend who's a member of Integrity had sent.

The coat of arms and "LAMBETH PALACE" on the letterhead are most impressive, but I suspect it's boilerplate, sent out to anyone inquiring about the invitations flap. I'll check with my friend to see if the text on his letter is the same or not.

If so, does Ruth Gledhill still get credit for the scoop, or no?

--Ginny Gibbs

http://www.archbishopofcanterbury.org/releases/070629.htm
Clarification - Friday June 29th - In relation to the Times report of 29th June that 'Gene Robinson is to be invited to the Lambeth Conference of the Anglican Church next summer', it should be noted that there is no change to the Archbishop of Canterbury's decision not to invite the Bishop of New Hampshire to the conference as a participating bishop. It is still being explored whether Bishop Robinson might attend in another status but no invitation has been issued. ENDS

Gledhill needs a fishing license.

Add your comments

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Reminder: At Episcopal Café, we hope to establish an ethic of transparency by requiring all contributors and commentators to make submissions under their real names. For more details see our Feedback Policy.

Advertising Space