Chicago Consultation responds to Archbishop Williams
The Chicago Consultation has released a response to the Archbishop of Canterbury's reaction to the election of Canon Glasspool as one of the Suffragan bishops of the Diocese of Los Angeles. The statement calls for the Communion to recognize the ministries of gay and lesbian Christians as the only way it can, "in the end", remain faithful to the Gospel.
We hope that when the Archbishop realizes the damage he has done to the Communion’s ministry among gay and lesbian Christians and those who seek justice for them, he will reconsider both the words he has spoken and the words he has not.”
The full statement follows:
CHICAGO, IL, December 7, 2009
The Chicago Consultation issued this statement today from its co-convener, the Rev. Lowell Grisham:
“For weeks the Archbishop of Canterbury has been silent as the Ugandan legislature considers making homosexuality a crime punishable by death. Lambeth Palace has let it be known that it was working behind the scenes to influence the situation because public confrontation would be counterproductive and disrespectful. Yet the election of the Rev. Canon Mary D. Glasspool, a remarkably qualified gay woman as a suffragan bishop of Los Angeles, incited the Archbishop’s immediate statement of alarm, implying there would be grave consequences unless bishops and standing committees in the Episcopal Church refused to consent to her election.
“Canon Glasspool is a qualified, respected and beloved servant of God whom the Diocese of Los Angeles has discerned has the gifts of the Spirit to help lead their ministry. She is no threat to the work of God or to Jesus’ commandment that we love our neighbor as ourselves. On the other hand, executing gay people and creating a state system of oppression is a gross violation of the spirit of the one who welcomed the outcast to his table. We are as perplexed by the Archbishop’s speedy condemnation of the former as we are by his prolonged silence of the latter.
“We believe that honoring the relationships and ministries of gay and lesbian Christians, is, in the end, the only way in which the Anglican Communion can be faithful to the Gospel of Jesus Christ. We hope that when the Archbishop realizes the damage he has done to the Communion’s ministry among gay and lesbian Christians and those who seek justice for them, he will reconsider both the words he has spoken and the words he has not.”
The Chicago Consultation, a group of Episcopal and Anglican bishops, clergy and lay people, supports the full inclusion of gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender Christians in the Episcopal Church and the worldwide Anglican Communion. To learn more about the Chicago Consultation, visit www.chicagoconsultation.org.

Spot on. Bravo! AMEN!
Susan Russell
Posted by revsusan
|
December 7, 2009 1:44 PM
Well said.
Posted by EH Culver
|
December 7, 2009 2:32 PM
I agree. Unfortunately if this were a simple matter of presenting a reasonable argument none of this would be necessary. There is an unknown factor here that we can only speculate about: what is the ABC really thinking?
Posted by Peter Pearson
|
December 7, 2009 4:27 PM
With a finalized Anglican Covenant sometime soon we will watch the ++ABC gather into the "first track" of his sort of Anglicanism those for whom homomisanthropy is settled doctrine and a preferred state of being.
Will we in TEC really care if we are excluded from the table where this ++ABC presides with Uganda to his right hand and Nigeria to his left?
Posted by Michael Russell
|
December 7, 2009 4:38 PM
From the Archbishop of Canterbury's Response to GC09:"5. In response, it needs to be made absolutely clear that, on the basis of repeated statements at the highest levels of the Communion's life, no Anglican has any business reinforcing prejudice against LGBT people, questioning their human dignity and civil liberties or their place within the Body of Christ. Our overall record as a Communion has not been consistent in this respect and this needs to be acknowledged with penitence."
If he and others are indeed "working behind the scenes" to prevent the passage of the pending legislation in Uganda, I hope that they will be successful. Nevertheless, his speaking out almost immediately on the Rev. Canon Glasspool's election while keeping silent on Uganda seems inconsistent and out of proportion to me.
Posted by EH Culver
|
December 7, 2009 4:46 PM
Addition to my previous comment on the Response of the Archbishop of Canterbury to GC09:
The pending legislation in Uganda goes far beyond "reinforcing prejudice against GLBT people, questioning their human dignity and civil liberties." The response from Lambeth needs to be commensurate with the seriousness of the pending laws, and I question whether "working behind the scenes" is.
Posted by EH Culver
|
December 7, 2009 5:02 PM
I keep waiting for uplifting and spiritually relevant messages from Lambeth Palace and The Archbishop of Canterbury...nothing but nonsense, and muddled resoning...admiring cherished gifts from a pope who lives in the home built by slaves and queers and does witchhunting on his days/daze off to distract us from his REAL sexual internal problems...and a Archbishop of York who has forgotten that he too was endangered refugee from bloodthirsty Uganda and GRANTED asylum in the U.K...he now goes by his ¨Lordship of York¨ and sings stupid songs demeaning GAY ANGLICANS...then there is a bunch of quacks worrying about the sexual appropriateness of what other people ¨do¨ in bed (while of course ignoring their own beastily record of conduct and unmissionary behavior)...who cares, the whole mess ought be auctioned off in England and the many Bishops palaces turned into homeless shelters, rehabs and housing for the tens of thousands of refugees coming from Uganda because of LGBT people our friends/families pending Genocide!
Rowan Williams gives fecklessness all new meaning.
Posted by Leonardo Ricardo
|
December 7, 2009 5:39 PM
I cannot but keep asking myself why ++Rowan keeps doing this. I really want to honor the office of the successor to the chair of Augustine. I really want to look to him for leadership in the Anglican Communion as the primus inter pares.
Unfortunately, the paired silence on the Ugandan humanitarian crisis (from the country that brought us such bright lights as Idi Amin, I might recall) and his immediate condemnation of the election in LA (where apparently the Holy Spirit has been banished) hurts and saddens and appalls.
I find myself thinking of the scene from "How the Grinch Stole Christmas" where Cindi Lou Who awakens to find "Santy Claus" stealing her Christmas tree. "Why, Santy? Why?" the little girl asks, unable to understand why someone dressed as her beloved Santa could behave in a manner so inconsistent with the clothes he was (deceptively) wearing.
In the midst of so much darkness, we can, I think, take some small comfort in the words of OUR presiding bishop's Christmas message:
"The mornings are dark, pitch black until after most of us have begun our days. The hints of dawn in the eastern sky, those streaks of rose and pink that promise more and brighter light, bring hope even in the dark mid-winter. Where do you look for that kind of hope borne on slim rays of light?"
I do not think, sadly, that there is much light coming to us from the chair of Augustine these days. More is the pity for our poor beleaguered church and world.
Posted by Jeffrey L. Shy, M.D.
|
December 7, 2009 5:58 PM
More comment on the statement here,
http://www.thinkinganglicans.org.uk/archives/004103.html#comments
Posted by John B. Chilton
|
December 8, 2009 12:46 PM