There's no place like home

By Jane Carol Redmont

My brother’s grandchildren look at me from the photos I have just received, fresh from the internet. They are at the beach, smiling under their cloth hats, cheeks round and dark eyes sparkling, the five-year-old boy and seven-month-old girl.

I wish I were there with them and their parents, my elder nephew and his wife. But the beach is in Portugal, where they live, thousands of miles away.

I have not yet met the baby. My plans to visit this summer have been scuttled by a combination of work and financial constraints. Family togetherness is expensive. Our immediate kin – my parents, their two children, and two more generations – are spread out over four countries.

We remain close. My brother and I exchange e-mails when he has just awakened in Italy and I am closing down the computer for the night in the U.S. My mother calls from Boston to ask about plans for a visit later in the summer and speaks of an old friend whose health is failing, of the presidential campaign, of her small garden plot, a raised bed which she tends at nearly ninety years of age.

A few days ago I spent the day at a small retreat center here in North Carolina, writing, resting, praying. After the afternoon thunderstorm, I walked the outdoor labyrinth on a path of pine needles bounded by large round stones. The air was full of birdsong. It was still humid, less thick than in the heat of the day but with a muggy texture that makes me miss the San Francisco Bay Area, where I lived for a decade before moving East three years ago.

At the entrance to the labyrinth is a stone birdbath. Or perhaps it is a holy water font – or both. It holds both soil at the bottom and fresh fallen rain. I am a Christian; I touch the water, make the sign of the cross. Walking the labyrinth, step by step, slowly, with no agenda or question in my mind, I follow the path. Images come to me of my family’s children, of the land where they live. I move back to the present, returning my attention to my steps, watching my feet, noticing thick tarpaulin where the bed of pine needles has thinned, walking. In my steps are the steps of my ancestors who came here as immigrants, mostly poor, some more privileged, all leaving their homes, never seeing their parents again. I walk, feeling this land, carrying other lands inside me.

I walk and remember the migrants and immigrants I met in Oregon eight summers ago, during a week-long walk for justice with labor and religious activists. For some, Spanish is a second language; they speak Mixteca and Zapoteca. In their bodies are layers of exile. I think of today’s migrants in Sudan, displaced by war and stalked by violence and hunger. My life is a palace compared to theirs.

Still, we share displacement and rebuilding, the tug toward and separation from family, the experience of communal bonds, accidental or intentional, that go beyond the kinship of blood. We take steps on foreign land.

On the same July 4 weekend as the children’s photos arrive, I hear from a high school friend from Paris. We have renewed contact after three decades, picking up where we left off, writing short, affectionate notes, celebrating a reunion with two other friends last fall. He writes a few lines from southeast France, where his parents have retired. The mere name of the town fills me with memories: stone houses, cobblestones, the smell of lavender and herbs in the surrounding countryside.

Later in the day, I attend a potluck party at the home of a couple of men who are friends from church and professional colleagues. We often spend holidays together: Easter dinner, Thanksgiving, sometimes our birthdays. We see each other more often than we see our families. We sing together at church, roll our eyes at stories from work, share news of our parents’ health. Today, on the Fourth of July, the house is full. Some of the guests have lived most of their lives here in the southern U.S. Others, like me, are recent transplants.

This land is not my land nor the land my body loves. It is not the place of my birth. In other ways it is becoming home, not least because of the church. These simultaneous truths speak to me as I walk, step by step, on a quiet summer evening in a labyrinth bounded with stone.

In the city of my birth, which will always be home, I am now also a stranger: I always return to visit, but have not lived there, by the Seine, since the year I turned twenty-one. In the city I miss, by the Pacific, where the air is soft and where I spent ten years, I could not live today. There is no work for me there.

Where is my land? Who are my people?

As a citizen of one nation raised in another, these questions used to haunt me, especially during my adolescent and young adult years. Later they mattered less, or mattered differently.

In some ways those of us who have lived astride cultures are a nation of our own. My family has and is its own culture. I have come to accept this.

In other ways my life has schooled me for the church, for broad belonging, for holding many people – and peoples – in my heart at once. It is no accident that theologies of the communion of saints and of the body of Christ are among those I treasure most and find most sustaining.

I still think a great deal about place, and belonging, and what it means to be a people or belong to a land. I think about home and exile.

With formative communities and loved ones in more than one culture, I am at home in several places. I also always miss someone or someplace – even when, adapting to a new location or tending to my present life, I may suppress for weeks on end the feelings of longing.

Paradoxically, it is in the taking of slow, mindful steps on the land where I now live that I can return fully to the memory of the other lands I love and of the people who live there.

My path may not be as unusual as it seems. Even those who have less migration and fewer cultures in their recent past carry the footsteps of their ancestors with them, learn and relearn a sense of place, discover the shape and meaning of kinship and friendship as they walk through life.

Jane Carol Redmont is theologian for the deacon formation program of the Diocese of North Carolina and chairs the diocesan Anti-Racism Committee. She teaches religious studies and women’s studies at Guilford College. Her book When in Doubt, Sing: Prayer in Daily Life will be published in a new edition by Ave Maria Press in October.

Comments (8)

Beautiful, Jane---thank you.

Paige Baker

I am reminded of the Exile theme in our tradition; our true home is with Godde and our fellow seekers. There is my land; they are my people.

The "land of my raisin'", as with many small towns, has vanished. I've lived almost a quarter century in another, very different part of the U S; I have never felt completely at home in either place, yet I feel a strong attachment to both.

A richly evocative essay; thanks (again)

John Wood

Friends of ours who now live in the Paris suburbs visited today. He is a native of New Orleans, as I am. She is French. R. and I talked about New Orleans and the sense of place. I have lived away from NO for 47 years now, but it's still the home of my heart. I'd live there if I could. He does not feel the same pull to NO that I do. Chacun à son goût.

Your essay on home and place fit my mood today quite well.

Thank you, Jane. It's fine writing.

I forgot to sign my name to the post above.

June Butler

Oh Jane- this is brilliant.

Who we are and where we belong are matters not of papers and citizenship, nor nationalism gone wild. Nor denominationalism gone wild either.

It is deep in our hearts.

Fran Rossi Szpylczyn

I agree with the comments above... very fine piece!

I think I have a couple similar feelings as yours in the first sentence of the 12th paragraph.

First one of which would be where I was born, Hong Kong. I haven't been there for 12 years. Hong Kong is always my home, since I lived there for the first 11 years of my life. Yet, having seen quite a bit of pictures from my friends making visits to there between 1996 and 2008, some of their pictures made me feel like a stranger again. Moreover, being nosy and checking on the faculty listing on my elementary school in Hong Kong, a lot of the teachers who taught me had either left or relocated somewhere else.

Then, for the most part until last year, I grew up in Chinese churches and have got used to Chinese services. So, Chinese churches (whether it's my Presbyterian church in Hong Kong or St. Gabriel's in Monterey Park, CA) had been my home for 22 years. But, now I am a stranger to Chinese churches because I had since relocated to Holy Trinity in Covina, CA. I did what I did because I felt God was calling on me to move on to that Holy Trinity. Technically, I had broken the norm for a person who's a first generation Chinese immigrant. Meanwhile, because of my relocation, I also now feel I am an outsider in Chinese and Asian ministries as well.

But, despite being a minority in Holy Trinity, I am making steps to be an active member there and make myself feel at home. Sure, people would probably not speak to me in Mandarin or Cantonese at church ever again. But, it doesn't mean I couldn't bring my Chinese culture to church whenever it's appropriate. In addition to being an active member, I am showing to the Chinese ministry community that one doesn't have to go to a Chinese church to do Chinese ministry. Rather, one just have to be a sound foundation of what the Chinese ministry is all about and use his/her creativeness to continue on, if God calls on him/her to be elsewhere.

- Bill Wong

Jane - I love this. It's beautiful and poignant.

I do think that being a part of and apart from so many places, helps to build genuine affection for those who have touched us.

Thank you.

Eileen Schilling

Bill, thank you for this moving testimony.

And thanks to all for your comments. Keep 'em coming.

These issues of home and displacement are common to many of us humans, I think. They are also related to how we understand the meaning of communion if we also happen to be Christians, especially liturgical and catholic (all kinds of catholic) ones.

Add your comments
Reminder: At Episcopal Café, we hope to establish an ethic of transparency by requiring all contributors and commentators to make submissions under their real names. For more details see our Feedback Policy.

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Advertising Space