Turmoil mongering
(UPDATED)
I have yet to read a story in the mainstream media that captures even a hint of the excitement that Bishop Jefferts Schori's election has engendered here in Columbus. People still can't believe that the bishops were brave enough to do it, and we are delighted with her initial encounters with the media. Amidst the forecasts of doom and gloom, I just want to offer a reminder that women with young children make most of the decisions in this country about who is going to go to church where. I think these women are going to respond very positively to what we've done, especially when they have a chance to see and hear Bishop Jefferts Schori. She is a powerful messenger. Looking at it from my own rather narrow viewpoint--My primary professional concern is making the Church look good so that we can grow--I think we chose the person most likely to help us do that.
As an example of the general lunkheadedness of the coverage so far, have a look at this piece in the Detroit Free Press.
The lead: COLUMBUS, Ohio -- The global Anglican Communion was in an uproar Monday over Sunday's decision by its U.S. branch, Episcopal Church USA, to name a woman as its next presiding bishop.
Only problem is, not one Anglican leaders worldwide is quoted in the story. Possibly because only Rowan Williams, the archbishop of Canterbury has issued a statement and it courteous, if rather over modulated. The story fails to support its primary assertion.
The first prize for hyperventilation, however, goes to the Times of London. Here is the lead it took two writers to devise:
"The Anglican Church descended into “ecclesiastical anarchy” last night as American traditionalists refused to accept the authority of a woman and asked the Archbishop of Canterbury to lead them instead."
For those of you not following the convention closely, what actually happened, was that one diocese, Fort Worth, which has already petitioned the Communion's panel of reference for alternative oversight, has renewed its request, this time with an appeal to Dr. Williams.
It is a curious requests because in the Episcopal Church, the Presiding Bishop does not exercise authority over dioceses. So Fort Worth is asking to get out form under that which is not on top of it. I am filing a request this morning to be free of the tyranny of the British king! It is as sensible a maneuver as what Forth Worth pulled yesterday, but I don't think it will make the papers.
Be not afraid folks. No matter how hard they try to scare you.

Well at least ENS gets it right in their story--"From Columbus: Anglican leaders reflect favorably on Jefferts Schori election."
See official church website for the article and the quotations from the supportive Anglican leaders.
Posted by Widening Gyre | June 20, 2006 8:35 AM
Jim -
Happy to report The Hartford Courant did a story on the election of +Katharine that conveys a lot of the good feeling. The Courant is _very_ mainstream, albeit in a small market.
Tim Cole
http://www.courant.com/hc-episcopalbishop0620.artjun19,0,4046082.story
Posted by teapeasea | June 20, 2006 1:23 PM
Can we add the IRS to the English king? Didn't think so.
When the Prince and Princess of Wales were planning a trip to Dallas, I consulted an etiquette book, just in case we encountered each other in the drive thru lane of the local Whataburger. Bow? Curtsy? "Get up," was the answer. "We fought a war not to have to do this."
With all due respect to the English bishops, ECUSA will continue to rely on Scripture, Tradition, Reason and, last but not least, the Holy Spirit for guidance in our dealings in the U.S. and with the rest of the world. We will listen to their opinions, but we will not be unduly influenced by them. And I seriously doubt that ECUSA will ever -
that's ever- be removed from the Anglican Communion and replaced by any group.
Posted by EHCulver | June 20, 2006 1:49 PM
I must take issue with your statement that "women with young children make most of the decisions in this country about who is going to go to church where."
I go to church wherever I want to go to church.
Thankfully, I want to go to church where my wife tells me we’re going to go so it all works out.
I have to agree with you that Bishop Jefferts Schori is a very good representative for the Episcopal Church. Unlike some of the religious leaders we see in the media so often (Pat Robertson) I think she can open her mouth without inserting her foot in it and is very likely to make the church look good (better) to a great many people.
Posted by DanielR | June 20, 2006 2:24 PM
I have found that the PBS news program Religion & Ethics Newsweekly has been steadfastly covering Convention almost every night, interviewing personallities on both sides of the issues.
Fox had a 5 second piece on the G Block but they didn't say much [doh!]. I have noticed on CNN the ticker has some updates but that's about it!
Posted by RevCatherine | June 20, 2006 7:05 PM